Hehe, j/k. This is one of the pumpkins we carved this weekend when we invited Susan's adorable nieces and nephews over to our place for our first housewarming. They had previously visited once while we were still moving and settling in and our place was a mess so there wasn't much for them to do. Even our attempts to bribe them with pizza were foiled when we walked over to Piece only to find that the wait would be over 45 mins that night. This was our chance to redeem ourselves and let's face it, our reputations were at stake here. I had to wow and dazzle them and subconsciously plant in their heads that Susan and Soomeenshee emo are really cool. Let me tell you, it ain't easy trying to impress, let alone keep the attention span of three kids under the age of 7. To aid us in our attempts, Susan and I bought three pumpkins for them to carve and we baked a bunch of sugar cookies for them to decorate.
In preparation for the big day, I asked a few friends for their go to recipes for sugar cookies and they gave me two recommendations. One is Alton Brown's recipe and the other is from Allrecipes.com. Being the nutcase that I am, I made a batch of each. In my defense, I didn't think one batch would be enough for 3 kids and 3 adults and two batches ended up being the perfect amount of cookies for us to decorate and eat in the end. They are both great recipes, but there are notable differences that are good to know for future use.
If I'm making straight up, unfrosted sugar cookies to eat, I'd go with the Allrecipes.com recipe because it puffs up into a cloud of soft goodnesss and has a nice vanilla flavor to it. However, if you're looking to cut out shapes and decorate them with frosting, Alton Brown's recipe is pretty darn fantastic. Alton Brown's cookies hold their shape well.
If I'm making straight up, unfrosted sugar cookies to eat, I'd go with the Allrecipes.com recipe because it puffs up into a cloud of soft goodnesss and has a nice vanilla flavor to it. However, if you're looking to cut out shapes and decorate them with frosting, Alton Brown's recipe is pretty darn fantastic. Alton Brown's cookies hold their shape well.